Amazon.es:Opiniones de clientes: An Echo in the Bone: Outlander, Book 7
Saltar al contenido principal
.es
Hola Elige tu dirección
Todos los departamentos
ES
Hola, identifícate
Cuenta y listas
Devoluciones y Pedidos
Cesta
Todo
Servicio al cliente con discapacidad Los más vendidos Amazon Basics Atención al Cliente Últimas Novedades Música Ofertas eBooks Kindle Informática Audible Prime Libros Hogar y cocina Cheques regalo Electrónica y Fotografía Moda Juguetes y juegos Bricolaje y herramientas Videojuegos Deportes y Aire libre Salud y cuidado personal Coche y moto Bebé Ideas para regalos Vender en Amazon Belleza Kit de Compras Suscríbete y ahorra Envío Gratis Lista de Deseos
Productos del momento en Libros
Amazon.es Los más vendidos Ofertas Productos Reacondicionados Lista de deseos Cheques regalo Amazon Prime Apps de Amazon Vender en Amazon Trabajar en Amazon

  • An Echo in the Bone: Outlander, Book 7
  • ›
  • Opiniones de clientes

Opiniones de clientes

4,7 de 5 estrellas
4,7 de 5
19.146 valoraciones globales
5 estrellas
83%
4 estrellas
11%
3 estrellas
3%
2 estrellas
1%
1 estrella
1%
An Echo in the Bone: Outlander, Book 7

An Echo in the Bone: Outlander, Book 7

porDiana Gabaldon
Escribir una opinión
Cómo funcionan las opiniones y las valoraciones de los clientes

Las opiniones de los clientes, incluidas las valoraciones del producto, ayudan a otros clientes a obtener más información sobre el producto y a decidir si es el adecuado para ellos.

Para calcular el desglose general de valoraciones y porcentajes, no utilizamos un simple promedio. Nuestro sistema también considera factores como cuán reciente es una reseña y si el autor de la opinión compró el producto en Amazon. También analiza las reseñas para verificar su fiabilidad.

Más información sobre cómo funcionan las opiniones de los clientes en Amazon
Ver opciones de compra

Principal comentario positivo

Todas las reseñas positivas›
MaríaD
5,0 de 5 estrellasUna edición bonita
Revisado en España 🇪🇸 el 23 de junio de 2022
La edición es preciosa. Con el uso y el tiempo se van despegando las esquinas de la portada y me dan ganas de forrar el libro para que no se estropee más, pero echaría a perder el brillo y el relieve de la cubierta. Es lo que tienen las tapas blandas. El libro en sí... ¿Qué decir de él? Sale James Fraser. ¿Qué más quieres?
Leer más

Principal comentario crítico

Todas las reseñas críticas›
Cliente Amazon
3,0 de 5 estrellasok but she's written better
Revisado en España 🇪🇸 el 8 de junio de 2020
alright but got a little boaring at times
Leer más

Buscar
Ordenar por
Reseñas más importantes
Filtrar por
Todos los autores de opiniones
1 estrella solo
Texto, imagen, vídeo
Filtrado por
1 estrellaBorrar filtro
246 valoraciones totales, 94 con reseñas

Ha surgido un problema al filtrar las opiniones justo en este momento. Vuelva a intentarlo en otro momento.

Traducir todas las reseñas al Español

Desde España

Hay 0 reseñas y 2 valoraciones de Españacon 1 estrella

De otros países

Pearl Hunter
1,0 de 5 estrellas so very disappointed
Revisado en los Estados Unidos 🇺🇸 el 25 de octubre de 2009
Compra verificada
As an avid fan of the Outlander series, I pre-ordered "An Echo in the Bone", excited to be reintroduced into the lives of Jamie and Claire.
I had problems with this book. She introduced way too many minor characters and to tell the truth, I didn't enjoy the book enough to go back and figure out when they had appeared (when did Dr. Hunter meet Dottie in London?) I have, in the past, loved the way D.Gabaldon inserted interesting scientific and historical facts into her stories, but this time, I felt that she had cut and paste battle statistics and chemistry facts from other books into hers. There seemed to be no love of the details, like in her previous books - more just a half-hearted repetition of a style that had worked in the past.
Why did we have to read chapter after chapter about William's spying and his love life and then not have anything resolved? Why didn't she curtail the extended battles scenes with William and why did she introduce the Percy, Beauchamp, Richardson and Randall storyline? That was approx. 1/3 of the book and went absolutely no where.
The ending was so blatantly commercial, it reminded me of a movie franchise, setting up a cliffhanger so we have to come back for the sequel - purely a money making venture. I personally won't be back. I will just re-read the first few books over again. I found that the only time I was really involved and couldn't put the book down was when she was on to Jamie, Claire and Ian. Unfortunately, I also realized there were only about 40 pages left and I thought to myself, there is absolutely no way she can resolve all these issues thoughtfully by the end of the book, so I knew I was going to be disappointed.
Whoever edited this book did a very poor job. There is no reason that the storyline should have been allowed to ramble on through all the battle scenes and then be cut short during the personal connections that we, as predominantly female readers, actually care about. The continuity was very faulty also, an example would be William and Ian's relationship. They went back and forth throughout the book knowing each other, than not knowing each other, and then knowing each other again. I felt that so much of the book was produced shoddily. I wonder what was going on in the author's life these last few years that she wasn't able to construct a book at the professional level that she has in the past. If this had been the first book in the series, I would never have continued on, it felt that amateur to me and I certainly will not recommend it. I wish her luck in the future and thank her for writing the series, but I think I am done.
A 106 personas les ha parecido esto útil
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
MK
1,0 de 5 estrellas Promising author gone for the easy money
Revisado en el Reino Unido 🇬🇧 el 14 de febrero de 2010
Compra verificada
As most of the reviewers, I have been an avid Jamie & Claire fan - for the first 5 volumes. I was entranced by the description of the characters, it was so lively you could see them in front of you (so much so, that I was nearly afraid of the movie plans, in case they put the wrong actors in!) Lovely scenes between Jamie and Claire, scenes that make you cry... mind blowing issues about the matter of time and space, unexpected turns, some ideas only conveyed by a sentence or two (for example, Claire finding the skull with silver in its tooth),lovely plots and turns. All threads went together logically... And then, Gabaldon became a star. What I think has happened is that she lost interest in the Jamie story (no wonder, what IS romantic about America that time?), did not really want to continue it, but there was financial gain in writing sequels - and there was fan club pressure. She always says, she writes in bits and pieces, which is ok if they are interwoven nicely. What I guess happened now is that she had some short beautiful Jamie-pieces written years ago in her drawer. She also had some scenes that she planned to put into a third book of the Lord John series. In the last case, it was either not enough, or the Publisher did not want another book in this series, which should come as a surprise to none, because it is boring from the first sentence, and she does not achieve to make Lord John alive. So, after four years of collecting pieces, and under some pressure to write a sequel, she crams them into a patchwork of unrelated stories, and her heart not being in it. Half a Lord John book, a quarter of a sequel to the Outlander series (with some of these lovely scenes - but few), and the rest rather weak 'fill the pages' stuff (including silly sex scenes). There is no cohesion, very little romantics or mystery, the plot (or the three unrelated plots) is fairly predictable, the characters do not act according to the personality she once gave them so vividly. Suddenly, everyone waves odd Gaelic words into their sentences (obviously, she went to a Gaelic course), however the German she tries to show off with is grotesquely incorrect. Gone the philosophy, gone the living characters...Even gone the intuition. Just two examples: If you hope that you have the opportunity to leave some letters for your daughter to read 200 years later, would you really fill them with stories about how the cat spilled the milk? Or, if you are an academic historian, and you would love to write a book about what really happened in the war, and you see things no historian ever knew - but of course you can't quote them as your own experience: Why did Roger, before he left, not write some 'contemporary notes', that he could then find in his real time where he hid them? Much more sophisticated and interesting than this gold... So, I feel betrayed. If she lost interest in her heroes - understandably, after that many years - why could she not just write a book half the size, and tell us how it all ends. Instead, she chooses the soap opera approach of raising your interest, then switching the scene (far too quickly), and then ending without an ending, in the hope that will force the reader to buy the next book, too. There was something of this already in the 6th volume, and as you see, I fell for it... But not next time. I will write my own ending to this (don't worry, I'll not publish it!!!), because I am afraid I might completely fall out of love with the characters if I read what she will do to them next! In sum: If you haven't read the first volumes, don't even try to read this, you won't understand most of it. It is even difficult for us fans to remember all threads, as there are years between the books. If you are one of the fans who followed the story over all these years, nothing I say will probably prevent you from reading this one. But be prepared of a huge disappointment. It's nothing like the first ones, actually, it is pretty boring. If you like historic novels, try Philippa Gregory instead.
A 33 personas les ha parecido esto útil
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
Steven J. Zawacki
1,0 de 5 estrellas Follow the Rules Please
Revisado en los Estados Unidos 🇺🇸 el 24 de septiembre de 2009
Compra verificada
I have just started reading Ms. Gabaldon's latest, and will surely update and improve her star rating after I wade my way through her latest magnum opus, BUT I can say this right away - I do not appreciate Lord John and his "son" the target of her opening chapter. Claire is the protagonist of this series, and it should be SHE who the novel begins with on page one, and no one else. Ms. Gabaldon has done this before and IMHO it doesn't work. We have waited and waited to read about Claire and Jamie, and you start with Lord John's "son"?

UPDATE (10/5/09) I did finish this novel to the very last word and have my final comments and update to the star-rating, which I would put at about 2-1/2. Let's say 3 in Amazon's system. Too bad Amazon's editing system won't let me change my original rating.

First the good. Diana Gabaldon is probably the best pure writer of historical fiction I have ever read. She may even be the best writer I have ever read, and since my favorite genre is historical fiction this is a very happy situation for me. I very much enjoyed the book and am not sorry I read it, but ...

All the outstanding writing technique in the world can not fix the tragedy of her novel's structure.

Not only does the novel NOT begin with the protagonist, who Ms. Gabaldon herself clearly identifies with first person pronouns in Chapter two, she does NOT end the novel with the protagonist either. In fact, she doesn't bother to end the novel at all. Her story has a beginning and a middle, but no end. Those who have read all of her Outlander series know that this criticism is not unique for An Echo in the Bone. If you're wondering why there isn't a movie for the first book, one really good reason is that it takes the first TWO books to get an ending to her story.

There is more than one chapter in AEITB that could be omitted WITH NO IMPACT TO THE STORY.

The pacing becomes frantic in the last fifty or so pages, almost as if Ms. Gabaldon was striving to meet a deadline.

Her sole antagonist (Arch Bug) is unbelievable.

I could go on, but suffice it to say, AEITB is her worst of the Outlander series.
A 27 personas les ha parecido esto útil
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
B54Boucher
1,0 de 5 estrellas Amazon Printing Error second time. Now waiting for the third book
Revisado en los Estados Unidos 🇺🇸 el 17 de septiembre de 2022
Compra verificada
I absolutely love the Outlander Series. I finished book 6 and couldn't wait to start An Echo In The Bone. A few pages in I was a little confused and then looked at the page numbers, they were all over the place. Page 30 and then page 33. I paged through the book and discovered the whole brand new book from Amazon was a mess. The one star is for Amazon not the series. All I can say is buy Local,
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
Deb Turner
1,0 de 5 estrellas Selling a book with known publishing problems is wrong....
Revisado en Canadá 🇨🇦 el 29 de agosto de 2022
Compra verificada
I just finished this book - a great read until you get to pages 780 and forward.....the published book does not have pages in sequence and it was very hard to follow the 4 - 5 story lines with page 780 followed by 783...then to 784 and next 803...I just googled this and it is a known publisher problem - why is the book still being sold then?
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
Alison Rodgers
1,0 de 5 estrellas Missing pages
Revisado en Canadá 🇨🇦 el 21 de octubre de 2022
Compra verificada
My book has missing pages. Several here and there. Very disappointing
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
Amazon Customer
1,0 de 5 estrellas Diabolical
Revisado en el Reino Unido 🇬🇧 el 4 de abril de 2019
Compra verificada
First of all, if you're reading this and you've only read as far as book 3 (Voyager) then do yourself a favour and stop there.
Don't pick up another one of these books, just pretend that Diana's editor had the nerve to tell her to quit and that was that. As it is, this novel is another in a string of barely believable, contrived, overlong, turgid reads.
There is a phenomenal amount of pointless detail and minutia that could have been cut with no detriment to the plot, such as it is.
The actions of the main characters are often inconsistent with their previous behaviour and demonstrated personality, such that you begin to think that it's a series about body-swappers rather than time travel.
And then of course you have the now familiar desperately reaching plots that reek of a lack of imagination and a sheer disrespect for the integrity of the story and the intelligence of the reader.
For my sins, I've foolishly started reading the next book and within 80 pages I'm wishing I hadn't bothered. It actually gets worse, quite farcical in fact.
So don't make my mistake, stop after Voyager and remember the first few stories for the quality works that they are.
I've heard in recent interviews that DG doesn't care about what her readers think. If you've read this book, you'll realise that already,
A 39 personas les ha parecido esto útil
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
Cat Woman
1,0 de 5 estrellas Help me out of this terrible time warp...
Revisado en los Estados Unidos 🇺🇸 el 20 de diciembre de 2009
Compra verificada
I believe in the possibility of just about anything, including the warp of Space/Time and the potential to travel through portals. What a story and what a read! It takes a truly gifted author to write historical fiction with a sci-fi premise that makes the characters credible and not read like a marvel comic book. I was enthralled by the first 4 Outlander books and it's been downhill from there. This latest book was such a downer, I won't go back to Frasier's Ridge or Diana Gabaldon's world again. I almost put it down after a few hundred pages but I forced myself to read on because I pre-ordered it and I figured it just had to redeem itself. It didn't.

This is the first time ever I've felt "ripped off" by a book. Why? The characters were always credible if larger than life. We liked them. Suddenly, the author has manipulated them and played them against type. They should have aged gracefully and become wiser. Please, don't expect us to buy any books about Claire & Jamie after the fiasco in bedroom at the end of this 800+ page page burner. The author killed off our caring for the characters. It's as if a bad director and horrible script writer took over towards the end of Casablanca and Jessica Simpson took on Lauren Bacall's role.

Even if the author could say, "Oops, sorry," and re-issue this book like a software update to everyone who bought it, they'll never get those images out of their heads. I don't want to hang out here any more.
A 22 personas les ha parecido esto útil
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
Avid Reader
1,0 de 5 estrellas What a letdown
Revisado en los Estados Unidos 🇺🇸 el 6 de junio de 2010
Compra verificada
I have been a huge fan of the Outlander series from the beginning. Lets admit that the reason we read the books is for the story of Jamie & Claire. So what happened to them in this book? This book went off on so many storylines that they were lost. I found myself skimming over the Lord John & William sections to get to the people who were the reason I bought the book in the first place. When I found Jamie & Claire, I got long, overdone stories about pirates and battles. Not what I wanted to read.

Although this is a series of books, all the previous volumes could almost be read by themselves and still make sense. If this book had continued to follow the story of Jamie & Claire, I would be sitting here wondering how I could wait for the next installment and I would have gladly bought the book when it came out. The series is so popular that this should be a given. I think Ms. Gabaldon has gotten greedy over time. There is no other way to justify the cliff hangers and open storylines left at the end of this book. Ms. Gabaldon should have had more faith in her fans. I loved the stories enough that I didn't have to be suckered into buying the next installment.

When the next installment is published, I think I will wait to read the reviews before I decide if I want to invest any more of my money or myself in this series. What a shame.
A 27 personas les ha parecido esto útil
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
SFlorman
1,0 de 5 estrellas This reprint edition is poorly bound, with random page order errors.
Revisado en los Estados Unidos 🇺🇸 el 16 de marzo de 2022
Compra verificada
I have now purchased two copies of this reprint paperback edition, and in both of them, pages 13-40 have been bound (glued) in random order. I was hoping that the first one was just a fluke, but they were both messed up. Obviously Bantam has a problem with a sizable run of this printing. If you order online, be prepared to return it; if you buy it in person (assuming you can find an actual bookstore in your community), check the page order beginning at page 12 to make sure they go in order before you buy.
A 3 personas les ha parecido esto útil
Informar de un abuso
Traducir reseña a Español
  • ←Página anterior
  • Página siguiente→

¿Necesita el servicio de asistencia al cliente? Haga clic aquí
‹ Mostrar todos los detalles para An Echo in the Bone: Outlander, Book 7

Productos que has visto recientemente y recomendaciones destacadas
›
Ver o modificar tu historial de navegación
Una vez que hayas visto páginas de detalles del producto, busca aquí la manera más fácil de navegar hasta las páginas en las que estás interesado.

Volver arriba
Conócenos
  • Trabajar en Amazon
  • Sobre Amazon.es
  • Sostenibilidad
  • Amazon Science
Gana dinero con nosotros
  • Vender en Amazon
  • Vender en Amazon Business
  • Vende en Amazon Handmade
  • Vende productos innovadores
  • Desarrolla y protege tu marca
  • Programa de afiliados
  • Logística de Amazon
  • Promociona tus productos
  • Publica tu libro en Kindle
  • Amazon Pay
  • Alojar un Amazon Hub
Métodos de pago Amazon
  • Métodos de pago
  • Conversor de divisas de Amazon
  • Cheques Regalo
  • Recarga online
  • Recarga en tienda
¿Necesitas ayuda?
  • Amazon y COVID-19
  • Localizar o gestionar compras
  • Tarifas y políticas de envío
  • Amazon Prime
  • Devolver o reemplazar productos
  • Reciclaje
  • Gestionar contenido y dispositivos
  • App Amazon
  • Amazon Assistant
  • Atención al Cliente
  • IVA sobre los bienes
  • Australia
  • Alemania
  • Brasil
  • Canadá
  • China
  • Estados Unidos
  • Francia
  • India
  • Italia
  • Japón
  • México
  • Países Bajos
  • Polonia
  • Emiratos Árabes Unidos
  • Reino Unido
  • Singapur
  • Turquía
Amazon Music
Transmite millones
de canciones
IberLibro
Libros, arte
& artículos de colección
Amazon Web Services
Servicios Cloud Computing
de Amazon
Book Depository
Libros con entrega gratis
en todo el mundo
Kindle Direct Publishing
Publica tu libro en papel y digital
de manera independiente
 
Productos Reacondicionados
Precios bajos en productos revisados por Amazon
Shopbop
Marcas
de moda de diseño
Amazon Business
Servicio para
clientes de empresa
Audible
Disfruta de miles de audiolibros y podcasts originales
 
  • Condiciones de Uso y Venta
  • Aviso de privacidad
  • Área legal
  • Cookies
  • Publicidad basada en intereses
© 1996-2023, Amazon.com, Inc. o sus afiliados